When a third touch still is not enough

Many readers wait for three touches and call a trendline valid. Here is why that rule still needs a reaction test and a clean swing definition.

Close view of a price chart used to count trendline touches

A popular habit in trendline work is to wait for three touches, then treat the line as settled. In class we still count touches — but we also ask what happened after each one.

Touches without reaction

If price kisses a candidate line and immediately continues through with wide ranges, that contact is a poor building block. Prefer touches that produce a pause, a narrower bar, or a clear rejection candle before adding the point to your set.

Swing definition first

Without an agreed swing high or low, “touch” becomes subjective. We mark swings with a simple two-bar (or three-bar) rule stated before the pencil moves. Only then do we attempt the line.

Channels inherit the same problem

A parallel channel built from soft touches will look orderly and still fail on the next session. If the primary trendline is shaky, do not force rails — leave the chart with a single line until a cleaner swing appears.

Classroom drill

On shared charts we often hide the rightmost third of the history, place a line with two solid reactions, then reveal price and score whether the third contact behaved like a test or a break. The scorekeeping keeps the conversation honest.

← All field notes